Jam or Cream First? The Great Scone Debate
Few topics ignite debate like the order of toppings on a scone. Some people are firm about putting jam first, while others say cream should go on the bottom. This friendly rivalry has lasted for generations, especially between Devon and Cornwall.
In this guide, we’ll look at both sides of the jam-or-cream-first debate and share what makes clotted cream unique. We’ll also answer the big question about how to pronounce scone. By the end, you’ll feel ready to share your preference at any afternoon tea.
What is a Cream Tea?
A cream tea is a simple meal of scones, clotted cream and jam, served with a pot of tea. It comes from the West Country, where dairy farming has influenced local food for centuries. Unlike a full afternoon tea, a cream tea leaves out the sandwiches and cakes and focuses just on the scones.
You’ll find cream teas in tea rooms, garden centres, and seaside cafés throughout Devon and Cornwall. In a full afternoon tea, scones are just one of three layers, along with savoury bites and sweet treats.
What is Clotted Cream?
Clotted cream is a thick, rich cream with a golden crust. It’s made by gently heating full-cream milk or cream, then letting it cool slowly in shallow pans. The thick layer that forms on top is skimmed off, giving clotted cream its heavy, spoonable texture.
Clotted cream must contain at lClotted cream has at least 55% butterfat, so it’s much richer than double or whipped cream. Cornish clotted cream earned Protected Designation of Origin status in 1998, meaning only cream made in Cornwall can use the name. Devon also has a claim, since monks at Tavistock Abbey are believed to have made clotted cream in the 14th century.
How Should Clotted Cream Taste?
Good clotted cream tastes sweet, nutty and slightly buttery, with a crust that adds a little extra depth. It should hold its shape on a spoon rather than running across the plate like single cream. That thickness is exactly why the order you add it matters so much to scone lovers everywhere.
How Do You Pronounce Scone?
The pronunciation of scone is almost as divisive as the order in which you add the toppings. Some people say it to rhyme with gone, while others are equally sure it should rhyme with stone. Both versions are accepted in British dictionaries, so neither choice is technically wrong.
The rhymes-with-gone version is especially common in the North and Scotland, where the scone is thought to have originated. The rhymes-with-stone pronunciation is more common across the Midlands and in Ireland. Like the jam-and-cream question, it often comes down to where you grew up and what your family always said.
The Devon Method: Cream First
In Devon, people put the cream on first, spreading it over the scone like butter. Then they add the jam on top, where it sits brightly on the cream. Supporters say this makes sense because clotted cream replaces the butter you’d usually spread first.
Devon fans also say the cream acts as a barrier, stopping the jam from soaking into a warm scone. This practical method keeps each mouthful balanced, especially when the scones are fresh from the oven.
The Cornish Method: Jam First
In Cornwall, people spread the jam first, then add a generous spoonful of clotted cream on top. Cornish supporters say this way, the cream shows off instead of being hidden under the jam. They also find it easier to spread jam on a warm scone than to put it on top of soft cream.
The jam-first method got a famous boost when a former royal chef said Queen Elizabeth II liked it that way. People in Cornwall loved the news, while those in Devon had some good-natured complaints. No matter which way you choose, everyone agrees that clotted cream and good strawberry jam are a must.
How We Serve Scones at Harbour House
At Harbour House, our afternoon tea comes with freshly baked plain and fruit scones, made with Bristol Pastry Kitchen. We serve them with homemade preserve and clotted cream on the side so that each guest can enjoy their own tradition. Since Bristol is outside both counties, we’re happy to stay neutral.
Our scones are the middle tier of a full afternoon tea, placed between savoury dishes and sweet treats. To learn more about each course, see our guide to traditional afternoon tea. Each afternoon tea is £30 per person and includes unlimited tea and coffee from Triple Co Roasters.
Settle the Scone Debate at Harbour House
Whether you prefer cream first, like Devon, or jam first, like Cornwall, there’s no wrong answer. The most important thing is a fresh scone, real clotted cream, good jam, and a hot cup of tea. The rest is just a fun reason to chat and laugh with friends.
We serve afternoon tea from 12-5pm, Monday to Saturday, on Bristol’s Floating Harbour. Book a table and try out your scone technique with us.
Leave a Reply